Skip to main content

Outed L.A. Times restaurant critic won’t stop writing reviews

For anyone who hasn't been following along, here is the story of S. Irene Virbila, the veteran Los Angeles Times restaurant critic, and Noah Ellis, the Beverly Hills restaurateur who outed her.
It began Tuesday night. Virbila and several friends had been waiting 45 minutes for a table at Red Medicine, a new Vietnamese food joint where Ellis is a managing partner. Upon learning that Virbila, who had logged her reservation under another name, was indeed Virbila, he marched up to her, snapped a photograph, and asked her entire party to leave. She was banned.
But worse -- since restaurant reviewers rely on anonymity to ensure unbiased service -- by Wednesday afternoon, Virbila's face was all over blogs like Gawker and Eater, which obtained the following comment from Ellis: "We didn't want her reviewing us. ... Our purpose for posting this is so that all restaurants can have a picture of her and make a decision as to whether or not they would like to serve her."
Ellis elaborated in a post on Red Medicine's Tumblr page: "We find that some of her reviews can be unnecessarily cruel and irrational, and that they have caused hard-working people in this industry to lose their jobs — we don't feel that they should be blind-sided by someone with no understanding of what it takes to run or work in a restaurant."
On Thursday, the story landed in the pages of the L.A. Times itself, which framed the incident as such: "And among foodies, the debate over anonymity — is it still possible or even advisable for a restaurant critic? — was on."
"The whole idea of anonymity is almost a moot point these days. … After you've done it for any length of time, a year or more, your image gets out, especially now with camera phones," San Francisco Chronicle restaurant critic Michael Bauer told the paper.
But Virbila said she felt violated nonetheless.
"She was upset because she has worked extremely hard for more than 15 years to maintain her anonymity in the L.A. restaurant scene," L.A. Times food editor Russ Parsons told one of his own reporters.
Other Times staffers seemed to have Virbila's back as well.
"So what's next? Movie makers banning the Wall Street Journal's Joe Morgenstern from the screening room because he might be too tough?" wrote media columnist James Rainey in a blog post. "Locking the Disney concert hall doors to L.A. Times classical music critic Mark Swed?"
As for Virbila's future as a restaurant critic, the Red Medicine incident is "definitely going to make my job more difficult to do," she told the Times.
But the paper will "continue with its plans to review Red Medicine" anyway, staff writer Rene Lynch reported.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Blake Griffin with his head at the rim

After knocking himself out of the 2009-10 season after hurting his knee during a dunk attempt, it's still OK to cringe a bit every time you see Blake Griffin (notes) readying a launch. And apparently, now we have to worry about his head knocking the rim just as much as his knees handling the descent. It speaks to the level of credibility that the Dunk Contest owns these days that when word hit Wednesday that Blake Griffin was open to the idea of entering the NBA's annual stuffing show, we were actually more concerned than excited. Would Griffin, clearly the master of the in-game dunk just two months into his NBA career, be able to in any way match his prowess in an exhibition setting? Was there a risk of him needlessly hurting himself in the process? About 11 minutes into Wednesday's Rockets/Clippers matchup, the worries became outright fears. Because Blake went and did this. That's a 6-9 guy jumping off a surgically repaired kneecap with his head at th...

Payroll tax cut worries Social Security advocates

WASHINGTON – President Barack Obama's plan to cut payroll taxes for a year would provide big savings for many workers, but makes Social Security advocates nervous that it could jeopardize the retirement program's finances. The plan is part of a package of tax cuts and extended unemployment benefits that Obama negotiated with Senate Republican leaders. It would cut workers' share of Social Security taxes by nearly one-third for 2011. Workers making $50,000 in wages would get a $1,000 tax cut; those making $100,000 would get a $2,000 tax cut. The government would borrow about $112 billion to make Social Security whole. Advocates and some lawmakers worry that relying on borrowed money to fund Social Security could eventually force it to compete with other federal programs for scarce dollars, leading to cuts. Social Security taxes "ought to be held sacrosanct," said Rep. Earl Pomeroy, D-N.D., chairman of the House Ways and Means subco...

China Gas Truck Explosion

BEIJING: At least 20 people were killed and 14 others injured on Friday in an explosion caused by a leak of an oil tank truck in south China s Guangdong province.'The explosion, which sparked a massive fire, took place on an expressway in the provincial capital of Guangzhou around 5.15am local time, a spokesman with the city s public security bureau said.He said 20 people were killed in the explosion.State-run Xinhua news agency reported that the 14 others who were injured in the incident have been hospitalised.The fire caused by the blast was brought under control around 8.30am local time, according to firefighters.